I prefer Viking #1 (and yes, he does look like a viking to me). I like the continuity of the scale mail between the torso and the legs, though, I agree the tied up boots look better. But, since you can't have both...
I would prefer him with: bare arms, fur cuff (dark grey to mach the cloak), and maybe a gladius instead of the sword, that'd be awesome.
Best,
Arnaud