although I am not familiar with the other playmofamilies (pirates is really my theme) I thing these legs come from a totally new plastic mould.
you are right about the "stockings" color - they look a bit odd when compared with the skin color of the clicky.
i would just like to point out 2 things, though:
- this pirate is not necessarily a caribbean one - there were pirates in many places in the world, even in the 18th century (the probable date for playmobil pirate theme).
portugal (my country) was still being attacked by algeria-based pirates by this time (many of them european renegades).
- some pirates liked to dress to impress, and many of them were wealthy privateers, opperating letter-of-marquee vessels.
they probably dressed just as nicely royal navy officers.
whatever their colors, dresses and shapes, i just hope that playmobil continues to make them - they are a superb theme