The first one is an absolute classic
He's been around since 1990!!! So 22 years is a long time to show how much popular he is!!! I think I have 20 of him. However, he lacks a belt... I have given him a light blue sword belt to match the one coming down his torso.
The other one is also very nice, but I don't like the boots much... I think he is useful for spare parts and customisation.
I think both must be part of ones collection, at least one of each, and stay as they are.
But if you really want to settle for one of them, go for 7676.